Share here

New York City is one of the most exciting cities in the world, but with so many neighborhoods to choose from, picking the right place to stay can be overwhelming. As a New York Native from the Bronx, you can count on me to give you honest and raw advice. I’m not here to sugarcoat. If it’s your first time you want to aim for safe neighborhoods that are close to the subway.

Whether you’re visiting for the first time or returning for another adventure, this guide will help you find the best neighborhood to match your travel style. Plus, I’ll share a few areas you might want to avoid.

Best Neighborhoods to Stay in NYC

Midtown Manhattan

a silhouette of a Black woman with afro staring out a tall high rise window during the day
The Views at Moxy NYC Chelsea

If it’s your first time in NYC, Midtown is a great option. You’ll be within walking distance of major attractions like Times Square, Broadway theaters, the Empire State Building, and Rockefeller Center. Hotels here tend to be on the pricier side, but you’ll save on transportation by being so central.

Here’s our favorite hotel in Midtown

Upper West Side

A quieter, residential area that’s still close to Central Park, the American Museum of Natural History, and Lincoln Center. This neighborhood is ideal for families and those looking for a more relaxed vibe while staying well-connected to the rest of the city.

My Hotel Recommendation: Arthouse Hotel

3. Harlem

street art in Harlem

Harlem is rich in history, culture, and fantastic food. You’ll find vibrant jazz clubs, soul food restaurants, and attractions like the Apollo Theater. Plus, Harlem offers more budget-friendly accommodation options while still being just a quick subway ride to Midtown.

My Hotel Recommendation: Stay in This Beautiful Harlem Home

4. Chelsea

open air cafe connected to moxy NYC Chelsea

For art lovers, Chelsea is a fantastic choice. Home to the High Line, Chelsea Market, and countless galleries, this neighborhood offers a mix of trendy boutique hotels and luxurious stays. It’s a great area for foodies and those who love exploring NYC’s creative side.

My Hotel Recommendation: Moxy Hotel Chelsea

5. Greenwich Village

The Village is known for its charming streets, lively music scene, and great cafes. It’s perfect for those who want a mix of culture, nightlife, and a bohemian atmosphere. Plus, it’s home to Washington Square Park, a favorite NYC landmark.

My Hotel Recommendation: The Marlton Hotel

6. Williamsburg (Brooklyn)

Dumbo Manhattan Bridge View during the winter and light snow if falling

If you prefer a hipster vibe, Williamsburg is the place to be. Packed with trendy coffee shops, vintage stores, and stunning skyline views from waterfront parks, it’s an excellent option for those looking to experience a different side of NYC.

My Hotel Recommendation: Wythe Hotel

7. Flatiron District

The Flatiron District is a fantastic choice for visitors who want to be near great restaurants, beautiful architecture, and easy access to multiple subway lines. You can read more about fun things to do in the Flatiron District here. This neighborhood is home to the iconic Flatiron Building, Madison Square Park, and Eataly, making it a foodie’s paradise. With a mix of historic charm and modern amenities, Flatiron offers a central yet slightly less hectic alternative to Midtown, making it ideal for travelers who want convenience without overwhelming crowds.

My Hotel Recommendation: Sonder Henri on 24

8. Long Island City (Queens)

As someone who hates crowds, I actually love Long Island City. It’s only one subway stop from Manhattan, but it’s much quieter and feels like the suburbs. But you also get amazing skyline views, affordable hotels, and a growing arts scene. It’s a great option for travelers who want affordability without being too far from the action.

My Hotel Recommendation: LIC Plaza Hotel

Neighborhoods to Avoid in New York City

Times Square

While it may seem like a dream to stay in the heart of Times Square, the reality is that it’s crowded, noisy, and overpriced. You’ll be better off staying in nearby Midtown or Chelsea for a more enjoyable experience.

My Hotel Recommendation: LUMA Hotel – Times Square

The Bronx (Certain Areas)

While The Bronx has great attractions like Yankee Stadium and The Bronx Zoo, some parts can be less tourist-friendly, especially for first-time visitors unfamiliar with the area. Plus, depending on where in the Bronx you decide to stay, it can add a lot of time to your commute into Manhattan or the Bronx.

My Hotel Recommendation: Opera House Hotel

Far East New York (Brooklyn)

This area is quite far from Manhattan and has limited tourist attractions, making it an inconvenient choice for visitors who want to maximize their time exploring NYC. Crime has also been a concern here. I have personally experienced gunfire in East New York. Granted it was during Labor Day weekend but no.

Best Neighborhood to Stay in NYC For Your First Visit

Choosing the right neighborhood can make or break your NYC trip. Whether you want to be in the heart of the action or prefer a quieter, more local vibe, there’s a perfect spot for you. Have a favorite NYC neighborhood to stay in? Let me know in the comments!

READ MORE
Did you find this post helpful? Please consider pinning it on Pinterest with the images below or following me on Instagram xoxo!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *